Current:Home > InvestHow ESG investing got tangled up in America's culture wars -AssetTrainer
How ESG investing got tangled up in America's culture wars
Surpassing View
Date:2025-04-09 01:27:04
A growing number of Republican politicians are moving to penalize Wall Street investors who consider environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues when they decide where to put clients' money.
In Florida, a state board chaired by Gov. Ron DeSantis recently barred investment fund managers and advisors from considering "social, political, or ideological interests" when making decisions for Florida's retirement system. In Texas and West Virginia, GOP leaders say they will block investors from state business who they claim "boycott" the fossil fuel industry. Fifteen other states are considering similar measures. And Republicans have said that if they retake Congress in the midterms, they plan to push federal legislation to curtail investment decisions they attack as "woke."
Anti-ESG Republicans say big financial firms are abusing their power to advance a liberal agenda on issues like diversity, social justice and, especially, climate change.
Many experts disagree, saying Republicans are distorting the goals and strategies of ESG investing.
It's hard for most people to get a clear read of what ESG is amid the overheated rhetoric. Is the idea to bring about social changes that couldn't be achieved at the ballot box? And what does it mean for things like your 401K when investors follow ESG principles?
This FAQ is for anyone who wants to better understand an investing trend that is becoming core to global financial markets and a new battlefront in American politics — including, possibly, in your own state.
What is ESG?
It's probably easiest to think of this as a set of considerations that investors are using to try to understand risks and opportunities that aren't accounted for in traditional financial models.
Climate change is one of the simplest examples: Investors are trying to find out how physical risks from things like rising sea levels and worsening drought could impact a company's operations. For example, does a company rely on water to operate its factories, or to move goods in places like Europe or China where rivers have dried to a trickle this summer?
Investors also want information about "transition risk" — how companies will fare as governments enact policies aimed at cutting emissions and demand grows for things like renewable energy and batteries.
"It's about looking at a business and saying, 'Are they prepared for the climate transition that's coming?'" says Witold Henisz, faculty director of the ESG Initiative at The Wharton School of Business at the University of Pennsylvania. "Some companies are, and some companies aren't. And that tilts your portfolio, it shifts your investment strategy."
ESG is different from impact investing, where the goal is to make money by investing in companies that are trying to achieve certain social or environmental outcomes.
"In our view, ESG is more of a sort of defensive framework," says Kunal Shah, a managing director at iCapital, a financial technology company. "Whereas impact investing ... is focused on investing in companies with a clear mission to make a change to the positive."
Are ESG investors boycotting fossil fuels?
It doesn't look that way. Big banks continue to provide hundreds of billions of dollars in financing to the fossil fuel industry every year. BlackRock, the world's largest asset manager and a favorite target of anti-ESG Republicans, is one of the top shareholders in many leading oil and gas companies.
"ESG isn't about a boycott," says Henisz of the Wharton School. "It's a question of which fossil fuel company do you hold? And how long do you hold them?"
In fact, BlackRock's CEO, Larry Fink, has said he thinks selling off fossil fuel stocks — or divestment — is an ineffective way to fight climate change. Instead, Fink has advocated for engagement, urging shareholders to press fossil fuel executives to be transparent about their plans for the future.
That said, it has gotten more expensive for fossil fuel companies to borrow money in recent years, reflecting the risks those companies face from climate change, says Tensie Whelan, director of New York University's Stern Center for Sustainable Business.
"It's not so much that [lenders are] punishing the companies. They're just saying, 'Hey, there's risk. And just like we would with any other products, we need to financially assess those risks and build them into the cost of credit,'" Whelan says.
Is ESG hurting the financial performance of companies or investors?
It doesn't appear to be.
NYU's Whelan co-authored a report examining the relationship between ESG and financial performance. After reviewing more than 1,000 research papers published between 2015 and 2020, Whelan's team found that corporate sustainability initiatives often seemed to drive better financial performance. They also found that in many cases, using ESG investment strategies appeared to deliver similar or better financial results compared to conventional approaches.
That doesn't mean proponents of ESG investing think it's being done perfectly. ESG disclosures vary from company to company. Ratings agencies that assess the data use proprietary methods, making it hard for investors to know how firms reach their conclusions. And there is growing concern that some asset managers are slapping ESG labels on funds that don't deserve them.
"The problem is we don't have good data," says Henisz of the Wharton School. "And so we struggle to measure whether companies are delivering."
Why is ESG becoming a political fight now?
Observers point to two potential factors, which aren't mutually exclusive.
One is that ESG — and climate considerations more broadly — are becoming ingrained deeply enough in corporate America and financial markets to begin changing the way some industries operate, says Mindy Lubber, CEO of Ceres, a sustainability nonprofit.
Hundreds of companies and investment firms, for example, have now promised to eliminate or offset their greenhouse gas emissions. Only a few years ago, there were hardly any.
The other explanation is that Republicans are trying to score political points ahead of elections.
"Taking climate risk as investment risk is just good business," says Henisz of the Wharton School. "Now, we can argue about how we do it and who does it well and who does it poorly. That's a legitimate argument. [But] the idea that ESG is ideological and not economics is a political argument."
veryGood! (25426)
Related
- Charges tied to China weigh on GM in Q4, but profit and revenue top expectations
- `The Honeymooners’ actress Joyce Randolph has died at 99; played Ed Norton’s wife, Trixie
- Emmys finally arrive for a changed Hollywood, as ‘Succession’ and ‘Last of Us’ vie for top awards
- Rewind It Back to the 2003 Emmys With These Star-Studded Photos
- Israel lets Palestinians go back to northern Gaza for first time in over a year as cease
- Lions fans ready to erupt after decades of waiting for their playoff moment
- Pope says he hopes to keep promise to visit native Argentina for first time since becoming pontiff
- Bitter cold front brings subzero temperatures, dangerous wind chills and snow to millions across U.S.
- North Carolina justices rule for restaurants in COVID
- Hamas fights with a patchwork of weapons built by Iran, China, Russia and North Korea
Ranking
- New data highlights 'achievement gap' for students in the US
- Dolphins vs. Chiefs NFL playoff game was 'most-streamed live event' ever, NBC says
- Washington Huskies hire Arizona's Jedd Fisch as next head coach, replacing Kalen DeBoer
- Australia celebrates Australian-born Mary Donaldson’s ascension to queen of Denmark
- At site of suspected mass killings, Syrians recall horrors, hope for answers
- Look Back at Chicago West's Cutest Pics
- Indonesia evacuates about 6,500 people on the island of Flores after a volcano spews clouds of ash
- This photo shows the moment Maine’s record high tide washed away more than 100-year-old fishing shacks
Recommendation
Federal appeals court upholds $14.25 million fine against Exxon for pollution in Texas
Georgia leaders propose $11.3M to improve reading as some lawmakers seek a more aggressive approach
Turkish strikes on infrastructure facilities wound 10 and cut off power in areas in northeast Syria
2 Navy SEALs missing after falling into water during mission off Somalia's coast
'Squid Game' without subtitles? Duolingo, Netflix encourage fans to learn Korean
Columns of tractors gather in Berlin for the climax of a week of protests by farmers
US delegation praises Taiwan’s democracy after pro-independence presidential candidate wins election
Turkish strikes on infrastructure facilities wound 10 and cut off power in areas in northeast Syria